The main dog food formats
Dry food (kibble)
The most widely used format. Produced by extrusion under high heat and pressure.
Pros: convenient, long shelf life, affordable, huge variety, mild mechanical dental cleaning effect.
Cons: extrusion degrades some vitamins and amino acids (which are spray-coated back on). Budget options often contain low-quality fillers. Low moisture content means the dog must drink more water.
How to choose a good kibble: named animal protein as the first ingredient (chicken, salmon, beef — not anonymous "poultry meal"), no artificial colours, no added sugar. Compare the guaranteed analysis for crude protein, crude fat and moisture.
Wet food (cans, pouches, trays)
Moisture content: 70–80%. Produced at lower temperatures than kibble.
Pros: higher palatability, higher moisture content (good for kidney health and dogs that drink little), lower caloric density per gram, suitable for dogs with dental problems or poor chewers.
Cons: more expensive than kibble, must be consumed within 24–48h of opening, no dental cleaning effect.
Fresh / gently cooked food
Nutritionally formulated meals made from recognisable ingredients (e.g. Butternut Box, Bella & Duke cooked range).
Pros: recognisable ingredients, high digestibility, less extreme processing, good nutritional control from companies with veterinary formulation.
Cons: most expensive option, requires refrigeration, not accessible for all budgets.
Raw food (BARF)
See dedicated BARF article for a full discussion of pros, risks and how to start safely.
Home-cooked food
Only under the supervision of a veterinary nutritionist. "Balanced" homemade recipes found online are typically deficient in minerals and vitamins. Chronic calcium deficiency in a homemade diet causes severe metabolic bone disease.
Can you mix formats?
Combining kibble and wet food is common and usually well-tolerated. Useful for increasing palatability, adding moisture, or as a topper. Adjust the total amount to avoid overfeeding.
How to read a food label
- Ingredient list: descending order by weight before processing. More weight ≠ more nutrition (water in raw meat counts heavily).
- Guaranteed analysis: crude protein, crude fat, moisture, ash. Always convert to dry matter basis to compare dry and wet foods fairly.
- FEDIAF/AAFCO statement: "complete and balanced for adult dogs/puppies" — the minimum assurance of nutritional completeness.
